In the play othello there are two characters that make the play what it is. In this book shakespeare uses different characters to bring out the theme of the book. The movies character roger is chided as a faggot while shakespeares rodrigo acts like an adolescent in love, speaking of suicide at the loss of the desdemona he never had the chance to love. Whether it is in the story plot, character, or even its setting, spotting the differences is always easy to find. Othello by william shakespeare and o directed by tim nelson are very similar in many ways. Her father saw it, and the defendant has testified as to his remarks. Home essay samples literature othello othello and o the movie. She is a nursing student studying at the university of new hampshire. In both versions, the michael cassio character is goaded into a drunken state, and a brawl ensues which damages his reputation. Tim blake nelson has creatively restructured othello into a film to appeal to a teenage. Like all shakespearen heroes, they all possess a tragic flaw that will eventually lead to their downfall.
This libretto is considered one of the great achievements in literature, as boito had to take an acknowledged masterpiece of world literature by shakespeare, condense it, musicalize it and make it work as well for the stage as the original. And on a deeper inspection there are striking similarities between the works of. As you can see from my comparison of tim blake nelsons movie o and shakespeares play othello we can gain a greater insight and engagement of the similarities between the two texts by a significant reflection of the differences between context and universal themes themes by the effective use of language and film techniques. O is set at a modern day prep school where their basketball team is fighting for the state title. Essay on a comparison of othello and the movie o 1548. Get an answer for what are the similarities and differences between the characters othello and oedipus. However, they were transferred into different situations and setting.
Othello differences and similarities of the movie and. The similarities and differences in their backgrounds, relationships to venetian society, and views on love fuel this relationship. The movie o was somewhat accurate to the play, othello, in which it is based upon. The film of othello by william shakespeare 1179 words cram. Comparison of oliver parkers 1995 film othello and. Othello is set in venice and the island of cyprus while there were wars. One of the clearest ways the film highlights the difference between the characters of langda and iago comes in the very last scene of the film.
Compare and contrast desdemona and emilia in othello by. Iago is always trying to hinder the moor, while othello continues his expression of honest virtues. Essay on a comparison of othello and the movie o 1548 words. What are the similarities and differences between the. Romeo, one of the main characters is a montague and juliet the other main character is a capulet. What are some similarities and differences between greek. Similarities between othello and iago 1146 words 5 pages. Many characters in o have a counterpart to othello. A version of the play othello written by william shakespeare that appeals to teens i. O othello movie analysis and summary schoolworkhelper.
Similarities between iago and othello 1014 words bartleby. Greek tragic theatre was primarily the delivery of lines by an actor wearing a mask. The movie s character roger is chided as a faggot while shakespeares rodrigo acts like an adolescent in love, speaking of suicide at the loss of the desdemona he never had the chance to love. Differentces and similarities of the movie othello and the movie o by djclueice3 oct 18, 2004 874 words. Macbeth vs othello william shakespeare is one of the greatest writers of all time. Many of these things you dont need, but are crucial to the plot of the book. O has a contemporary setting and most of the verse dialogue is rewritten as modern prose. An example of this would be othello which has been created into a movie called o. Apr 21, 2019 greek tragic theatre was primarily the delivery of lines by an actor wearing a mask. Comparisons of shakespeares othello and the movie o essay. Differences between film and play othello delving deeper. Desdemona, othello s wife, and emilia, iagos wife, are the two main female characters of the play. The two main characters in the play othello are othello.
The moor recontextualized othello to omkara silhouette magazine. O has a contemporary setting and most of the verse dialogue is. Get essay hugo also uses almost the same methods as iago in deceiving odin. In almost every movie based on a literary work, there are always major differences. A comparison of othello and the movie o 1551 words 123. Whilst human emotions such as jealousy remain universal despite context, attitudes and values must be continually challenged and. Choices in the movie o a young boy named hugo feels neglected by his father causing him to twist the minds of friends and family making it easy for him to get revenge on odin a basketball player who he feels receives more attention from his father then he does. Differentces and similarities of the movie othello and the. In the movie by rupert goold the setting of the play is in the 1900s when world war ii was taking place. A comparison of othello and the movie o when shakespeare composed the tragedy othello televisions were not.
Though it follows the plays action, parkers othello can be compared to the original play othello so that both the similarities and differences can be assessed. Odin to othello, desi to desdemona, hugo to iago, emily. Comparison on the movie and the book to kill a mockingbird essay. Literary similarities between marlowe and shakespeare. Along with no televisions, life in the late 1500s had many different qualities than it does today. The moor recontextualized othello to omkara silhouette.
Do they both express the same themes, characters, plot or ending. Nelsons movie, o, came out in 2001, starring mekhi phifer as odin othello, julia stiles as desi desdemona, and. The main difference between the play and the movie is the setting. Oliver parkers othello, released in 1995, is a more modern version of shakespeares classic play in the form of film. Othello a comparison of iago and desdemona, an essay fiction. The movie othello has many similarities to the actually play, while the movie o has more differences. A comparison of othello and the movie o 1551 words 123 help me. The movie o has those same characteristics with the characters roles. Although some lines are taking out and some scenes are added in, the movie gives viewers a new way of seeing othello without diverting too far from the original story. Othello throughout hollywood history, many screen adaptations of famous books and novels have strayed away from its original. Written in 1604, it has spanned a total of 12 movie adaptations othello, including the 2001 version directed by tim blake nelson. O the main differences between the play and movie although the movie o is a production based on shakespe atomic number 18s othello, several differences follow between the two such as womens brotherly status, iagos personality change. Varmas sarkar in that it takes the gruff realism of modern indian gangster pictures and applies it to politics rather than the criminal world the point being, of course, that there isnt that much difference between the two. Romeo and juliet is one of the many plays written by william shakespeare.
Nelsons o is heavily based on shakespeares original but is set in a modern setting, with high school students playing the roles crafted by shakespeare. Iago is in constant collusion for malignant ends while desdemona is a candid and reputable human being who wishes no harm to anyone. Compare movie and play othello many shakespearean plays have been utilized by hollywood. Shakespeares play othello vs nelsons film o english. What is the difference between othello in the movie othello masterpiece theater and the movie o. Othello and iago are both military men with strong fighting abilities however. Othello goes to high school, welsh 225 is an accurate description of the movie o as directed by tim blake nelson.
The similarities between the movie and the book at this point are, in the book the post of othello s lieutenant is given to michael cassio and not iago, just like in the film were hugo is not given the place as odins go to guy. Comparative study between othello and o the movie anonymous 11th grade. That is to say, they all follow classically great men from great heights to terrible ends and deaths. Odin to othello, desi to desdemona, hugo to iago, emily to emilia, roger to roderigo, and michel to cassio. The core comparison that springs to mind between these two plays, othello and hamlet, is that these are both tragedies driven by character. O the movie portrays the main characters in various similarities and differences. This time period had no war on drugs and no high school shootings. Othello and iago both compare in their dedication towards others but not for alike reasons.
In othello, othello and iago are the main characters with the former being the villain. Compare and contrast othello and iago in othello by. The similarities between the movie and the book at this point are, in the book the post of othellos lieutenant is given to michael cassio and not iago, just like in the. Comparison othello play and film english literature essay. May 10, 2015 othello 1995 directed by oliver parker is an excellent adaptation of william shakespeares the tragedy of othello, the moor of venice. Apr 22, 2011 the main difference between the play and the movie is the setting. Nov 10, 2009 the 1995 film version pitted laurence fishburnes othello against kenneth branaghs iago and the 2001 adaptation called o relocated the othello story to a south carolina school. What is the difference between othello in the movie. All the content of this sample reflects her knowledge and personal opinion on comparisons of shakespeare s othello and the movie o and can be used only as a source of ideas for writing.
In othello, iago uses roderigo for his own purposes, in omkara, though, there is a friendship that exists between langda and rajju even before langda begins planning his revenge. The film o consist of many similar elements from the original play, othello. Othello and iago are both military men with strong fighting abilities. The two main characters in the play othello are othello and iago. Othello comparisoncontrast by brittany washington on prezi. Literature can be viewed as a manifestation of the context it is composed in, whilst retaining universal elements such as the human experience. Join now log in home literature essays o film comparative study between othello and o the movie othello comparative study between othello and o the movie anonymous 11th grade. Nelsons 2000 movie production of o shows differences as well as similarities to the original. A difference that the movie othello and the movie o have is. A comparison of shakespeares plays macbeth and othello. The working title for the film was at one time the same as shakespeares play, but it was changed to the initial letter, which has resulted in a widening series of onomastic, sports, mythological, literary, and philosophical associations. Asked in drama and acting, performing arts, the difference between, similarities between. Othello differences and similarities of the movie and play essay. It is the greeneyed monster which doth mock the meat it feeds on that also make othello so riveting.
But omkara is pretty wellbalanced between these types of questions and the more intimate dynamics and wordplay o, beware, my lord, of jealousy. Each of these versions maintains fidelity to shakespeare where the black protagonist gets involved in murder and jealousy. Otello and othello the great italian poet and composer arrigo boito was the librettist for verdis otello. Hugo convinces michael to ask for desis help in pleading with odin to cancel his suspension and hugo also uses a piece of clothing that belongs to desi to convince. Difference betwen iago and othello the main difference between iago and othello is that iago was intelligent enough to use every characters he can to fulfill his revenge. Othello comes to venice to lead them against the turks. Differences between film and play othello the 1995 film adaptation of othello is a very well done film that gives watchers a new way of seeing the tragic story of othello. Othello is set in venice and the island of cyprus while there were wars between venice and turkey.
Comparison and contrast between othello and hamlet. The main similarity that both movies have is that everything happened because of iagohugos plot against othello that was ruled by his jealousy. Othello differences and similarities of the movie and play. Othello 1995 directed by oliver parker is an excellent adaptation of william shakespeares the tragedy of othello, the moor of venice. Othello iago and desdemona are among the two most distinct characters in all of shakespeares plays. Othello, the main character, is no exception to this and neither was m.
The o movie is a modification of othello by william shakespeare and is set in the 20th century in a high school, where odin in contrast to othello is a star basketball star and dating desi, desdemona in the play. Comparisons between the play othello and the movie o jenny. As the author of to kill a mockingbird, reading othello was quite an interesting experience for me, and i spotted many similarities between my work and shakespeares. They both have many differences as well as similarities.
The similarities between them make o an excellent rendition of the original. Get an answer for compare and contrast othello and iago in othello by shakespeare. The play is a tragedy about two starcrossed young lovers whose deaths eventually reconciled their feuding families. The roles played were formulaic, actors did not add their own representations, nor did they add individual expressiveness to their part. The themes of jealousy, racial bias, and deceit function as structure for both. Many things that are in the book arent in the movie. This is reflected in shakespeares othello and tim blake nelsons o. Even thought, the movie departs from the original play, due to the cutting of many dialogues, and an addition of new scenes, still this infusion of the authors vision and shakespearean genius not only changes a common perspective of the play, but.
O essays many shakespearean plays have been used by hollywood. This paper considers the similarities and differences between two versions of othello. Othello is one of the brilliant plays written by william shakespeare. I have to do an essay on othello, the differences between the book and the film. This is not an example of the work written by professional essay writers. O film essay comparative study between othello and o the. The plot remains the same, as do the characters, and the setting as parker chooses to film it as the original time period and locations. There are several diffrences between the play and the movie but the main diffrence is the setting of the two. Can someone whos both read and seen othello help me out. Analysis of adaptation othello 1995 by oliver parker. Comparisons between the play othello and the movie o. Literary similarities between marlowe and shakespeare introduction many readers, critics and biographers have noted the close similarity between the works of marlowe and shakespeares poetry and plays.
Macbeth and all the other characters are in a nazibased area. Differentces and similarities of the movie othello and the movie. Othello and o the movie o by tim blake nelson is based on shakespeares play othello. Iago is always trying to hinder the moor, while othello. The similarities between the movie o and shakespeares othello leave no question as to the heritage of this updated production. This essay looks at the summary of othello, differences of the two characters, othello and iago and the similarities of these two characters. What is the difference between the othello movie and play. The similarities between the movie and the book at this point are, in the book the post of othellos lieutenant is given to michael cassio and not iago, just like in the film were hugo is not given the place as odins go to guy. In the play, othello and desdemona marry while in the movie, they are only high.
1267 306 1150 940 1104 121 247 727 186 1110 1220 836 833 966 582 1558 1038 609 537 84 1549 872 1214 859 415 420 1106 1422 691 1440 362 26 468 1275 824 751 368 866 977 747 1381 736 545 239 205 85